We’ve been pretty undecided on the whole Santa front. One one hand there’s the added magic of a season full of wonderful things and the whole fun of playing along with kids who have such marvelous imaginations. On the other hand, there’re the problems that come with the eventual realization that it’s fake (”You lied to me?!”) and it seems that in these days of emphasized privacy and security, many kids are freaked out by the idea that a strange man ’sees you when you’re sleeping’ and steals silently into your house in the night, eats your snacks and, if you’ve been good leaves you a gift.
A lot of parents bank on getting December to run a little more smoothly with the threat that if you don’t get your act together this instant, Santa may consider crossing you off his list. Power to you, but I personally can’t help feeling like it’s a cop-out, hehe. Screw discipline and learning respect, the strange fat bearded man in perpetual jammies will not bring you that lego if you fight with your brother!
When I was little.. well, and even now.. I was/am the youngest of 5 -and 12 years younger than my eldest sister. I don’t recall ever thinking Santa was real. Maybe I did, but I don’t remember and I certainly don’t recall feeling devastated upon realizing the truth. I remember getting a gift labelled, “From Santa.” We used to open all of our gifts after Midnight Mass, which was awesome. (Maybe that’s when Santa’d come?) Regardless, to me, that was a big part of the magic of Christmas, being up so late, going to church in our best clothes, singing carols during mass, then coming home to chocolate and toys. I have no idea how Mom managed to get us to bed after that. I’m sure the crash wasn’t too long coming, though.
Now that Theya’s a bit older with better memories, imagination and has been tossed into the stewing pot of popular culture as she interacts with her school friends and school activities, I was starting to reconsider the whole Santa thing. I don’t want her ruining it for her friends who do believe in Santa. I don’t want her coming home crying when a friend spills the beans, either.
Last week I found a letter addressed to Theya in her Petite Sac (homework bag) so we opened it together. On the front was a drawing of a pegasus:

I am SO keeping this forever
On the back was a reply! It appears that they had some of the older grade students write out responses to the younger kids (spelling mistakes, etc, very cute), promising that he was working hard on the gift and that he hopes Theya is sleeping well the night he comes by.
In awe, Theya turned to me and asked, “Is Santa real?!” How could I say no? How could I say yes? Thinking carefully, I told her, “Honey, sometimes believing in something makes it real.”
SCORE
I didn’t lie to her and I left it to her imagination and wonder to decide. She thought about it for a moment (I admire her consideration), and decided, “Yes, Momma, I think he’s real.” So, we made sure to get a small pegasus* for her to find under the tree Christmas morning.
She understands that the Mall Santas are not the Santa, but some of his helpers that pass on info and spread seasonal cheer. She mentioned one day that she’d like to get a photo with Santa so I made plans to hit the mall the next day. When preparing to leave, I mentioned it to her (better wear something special) and, panicked, wide-eyed, she paused, then announced, “Maybe next year.”
*An interesting idea that came up while chatting with the moms at J’s work party: not all kids’ families can afford for ‘Santa’ to bring them a NintendoDS -if anything at all. A thoughtful plan is to make the gift from Santa a modest one. It would be crushing for kids to be comparing gifts in January and find out that Billy got a NDS and Timmy got snowpants. Life can be roughly competitive as it is without Santa picking favorites.
Addendum: I started this post because Ada asked on Twitter, “for those that celebrate Yule and not Christmas: how do you prevent your little ones from spoiling the Santa question?” and, obviously, I forgot somewhere about that topic.
I suppose our kids are spoiled in a way, we celebrate both Yule and Christmas. On Yule, we do a small family celebration at home and open our gifts to each other. Then we open the rest of the family gifts with our extended family as we see them on Christmas morning and the days that follow. We don’t get extra gifts because of it, they’re just spread out. Santa is still associated with Christmas.
I like this set up because there’s less of a toy overload all at once but more so because I like to think that it will encourage a respect for the celebrations and, more importantly, beliefs of others. J & I were both raised Catholic and while we’ve veered off that road for ourselves, we have no intention of denying or rejecting Christmas as it is observed by the majority of both our families. If believing in something makes it real, each cultural, religious or personal celebration is real. And I personally can’t get enough of celebrating!